Does Evolution = Martyrdom ?
- Login or register to post comments
- Print this page
I can't count the number of conversations I have had with my husband regarding changes that need to be made in our (okay, MY) lifestyle in order to make life better for our soon-to-be-born child and thus, for the world. I understand his ideas and the goals behind them, but I can't help feeling like I will have to become a martyr for the cause.
To be clear, there are a few major topics over which we have had circular discussions which leave me understanding what I must do and the benefits, but at the same time hesitant about what I must sacrifice.
They are: TECHNOLOGY, ENTERTAINMENT, CONSUMERISM, FOOD and INSTITUTIONS
TECHNOLOGY: There are a few conveniences that my husband is more that willing to give up, but that I am still very resistant to. The major one on which we cannot seem to agree is not owning a clothes dryer. There is a washing machine in the basement, but no dryer. My husband simply washes his clothes and then hang dries them. Up until now, I have been bringing my laundry to my mother's house and washing it there while I visit. For some reason, I would rather lump my clothes to her house than have to wait for my items to dry (mainly because I often wait until I have begin to blur the lines of clean and dirty before doing laundry and at which point, cannot wait an extra day for things to dry).
With the baby coming any day, I am worried about this arrangement. I am no stranger to how much laundry this little munchkin will go through each day and I worry that hang drying or laundry lumping will be too time consuming. My mother and grandmother have offered to chip in and purchase a dryer for us, but my husband strongly protests. Although I COULD hang dry the baby's clothes (especially since the warm weather is approaching and we have a massive porch which faces the sun for most of the day) I worry that it will take too much time. For example, if the baby is napping and I have an hour or two to get some things done, I would rather not spend all of it fastening tiny items of clothing to a drying rack when I could just toss clothes into a dryer and move on to something else.
After many discussions, after which both of us feel dissatisfied with one anothers' unwillingness to budge, I have decided to give the no-dryer thing a change, but reserve the right to take my family up on their offer to buy us one if I feel the need. I don't feel as though I should have to become a pioneer in order to provide the child with a better life.
Technology (or lack there of) = Martyrdom
ENTERTAINMENT: My husband and I do not have cable hooked up in our apartment. We do have a television and a DVD player and subscribe to Netflix...most of our movie watching took place while I was on bed rest and now is limited to before bed at night. I'm sure that once the baby comes, it will hardly be used at all. This was not an easy change at first. I am (or was) a T.V. junkie and could often be found spending hours in front of the tube watching mindlessly awful programs such as "The Real Housewives of New York City" and "Celebrity Rehab with Dr. Drew". I know that my time could be much better spent reading or cleaning or anything other than that and so I did not fight my husband for too long about getting cable hooked up. I still go to my mother's house on Tuesdays to watch LOST and can be found watching "junk food telelvison" downstairs in my mother-in-law's apartment, but overall the sacrifice is worth the gain. I feel much more stimulated by conversation and reading and as I said, the baby will not allow for such a waste of time to continue.
And although I may feel out of the loop when my friends and coworkers discuss the happenings on their favorite shows during our lunch break, it will be with a smile because I will think about the time I spent NOT watching T.V. because I was living my life with my family.
Entertainment? I am feeling like less and less of a martyr every day.
CONSUMERISM: Similar to Food, I also consume like an American. I let advertisements and labels tell me what items I need and then I buy them. I'm starting to discover that the majority of products that I used to purchase and thought nothing of, are easily made at home or substituted for much less harmful/wasteful products. For example, who needs Brillo pads when you have baking soda? In fact, who needs about 20 other household items when you have baking soda... it's quite the cure-all and is much less harmful to the environment than all of the things that it can replace.
I still, however, have been unable to give up using paper towels. My husband uses dish rags to clean even the most hideous of messes (these usually involve one of our dogs and will soon involve our child, to be sure). He wipes the mess and will return to the bathroom to rinse the rag several times until cleanliness is achieved. When I come across such a mess, I reach for the paper towels and use as many as necessary and then throw them away. My current excuse is that I am hugely pregnant and do not have the physical endurance to squat and wipe for longer than a few minutes, let alone travel back and forth from the bathroom to the mess, bending down each time (and taking even longer to get back up) in order to be less wasteful. My future excuse will most likely be that I am so busy with the baby, I just don't have time to do it his way. This sounds stupid, even to me, and thus I'm sure that eventually I will succumb to reusable resources. If I can agree to cloth diapers at home, I shoud be able to give up paper towels.
So therefore, martyr status for Consumerism: Minuscule
FOOD: I have been working on this one for a very long time and it doesn't seem to be quite as difficult as I had originally thought. (This fact makes me wonder if this is how I will eventually feel about ALL of the areas of change once I have been at them long enough.)
It has come to my attention that I eat like a typical American. For example, I am sometimes lazy and prefer to make something to eat that comes out of a box and can be popped in the toaster for 10 minutes, i.e. Ellio's Pizza. My husband refers to it as cardboard topped with ketchup and cheese. Why not MAKE a pizza and even *gasp* put some veggies on it? Although I consider such frozen treats to be comfort foods, I knew that he was right (and frankly, didn't want to listen to him about it anymore) so I bid a fond farewell to the frozen section of the grocery store.
We all know how Americans eat. Giant portions, too much salt, lots of meat and some items that push the limits of what can be recognized as "food" such as cheese in a can, etc.
We purchased the book, "Food Rules" by Michael Pollan. As I read it, I felt like the book was written by my husband. I realized that he wanted me to read it so that I would hear it from someone other than him. (For example, If your grandmother wouldn't recognize it as food, it isn't.) So, I get it. Eat less like an American and more like someone who cares what goes into their body.
Although it is sometimes difficult, and I can be found eating at a restaurant chain with giant portions (which I never finish anyhow) and over-salted meat dishes, it is a rare occasion and one that I feel a tiny bit of guilt for afterward. My urge to do so is, in fact, dwindling.
I have given Pollan's book to my mother in hopes that when I go to her house for dinner, there will be some efforts made to eat "real food" there as well.
Overall, I discovered that sacrificing a few extra minutes and making something fresh makes a huge difference and is not as difficult as I had thought.
FOOD does NOT = Martyrdom.
INSTITUTIONS: This pretty much means public schooling. My husband is adamant about homeschooling our child. This was the first discussion we had when I first became pregnant that made me wonder if I had made a baby with the right person. Since I work as a teacher's aide in a public school, I was initially offended. Did this mean that he has no respect for the work I do?
Over months and months of discussion about what homeschooling can offer our child versus sending them to a public school simply because "I went and I'm okay", I began understanding where he was coming from. After a while, I starting looking around the classrooms and seeing that there was so much more that the kids could be learning, but because of things like budget and class size, the kids were more often than not, getting only the tips of many icebergs of knowledge.
When my husband started talking about curriculum and what we, as parents, can add to the standard, I began to see that sending our child to a public institution was out of the question. Now, he has taken it a step further and has begun discussing the relationship between schools and prions. Extreme, I know, or thought at first, but the similarities are awe-striking. We've been reading a book by Derick Jensen, one of his favorite authors called, "Walking on Water". Once again, it took another voice to help me see the method to what I once though was my husband's madness.
Why wouldn't I want to take the time to educate my child and teach him or her not only the basics, but also EVERYTHING ELSE?
Our child isn't even born yet and already we are facing adversity from friends and family regarding our choice to home school. They express concern for things like the child's socialization and feeling out cast. No matter what we say in response, we know that will just have to let them wait and see the results. We are more than confident that words will be eaten.
It was a long road for me, but I am happy to say that...
INSTITUTIONS = Martyrdom - AND PROUD OF IT!!!
Overall, I am getting there. What I have realized is that changes of this magnitude take time and a lot of effort and that it's okay to slip up from time to time. Things that I used to think of as non-negotiable are now common practice. The fact that we are even thinking of these things, let alone putting some of them into practice, is a big step and one that is already benefitting our baby. He or she will grow up with these things as normalcy instead of a struggle and will therefore find it much easier to live this ever-evolving lifestyle. We hope to surround this child with others who are at least entertaining the idea of doing the same.
If we all stay strong and do our best, difficult as it may be, perhaps evolution won't have to feel like martyrdom in as little as one generation from now.
Comments
Is it really martyrdom to do
Is it really martyrdom to do what is beneficial for the whole of all sentient beings? Do you want your child to grow up in the middle of the same patterns you were conditioned into or would you rather show your child a simpler way of life that is in harmony with Nature.
It's easy to call it martyrdom when you compare yourself to the "Average Joe" painted up by the American Dream, of course living a simple life seems like a tremendous sacrifice compared to your normal American, but I feel our perspective would prosper if we tried comparing ourselves to indigenous people instead - is it really a sacrifice to live in harmony with nature? Perhaps it's an honor. Life is Sacred.
Many Blessings to you and your family.
In Lak'Ech, I am another yourself.
If it feels like Martyrdom and your not a Martyr.....
I notice a lot of folks with some level of good intent putting forth their ideas as if they were truth rather than opinion. Further I notice many that are interested in alternative and sustainable lifestyles have nearly the same level of preachiness and fervor as any evangelical.
It's annoying from coming from Christians and it's super annoying coming from the progressive/alternative community. It strikes me as little more arrogance.
I personally dumped the Martyr approach and have never regretted it. I would advise you to do the same. Unless you are a Martyr, trying to make changes that feel like Martyrdom wont work.
If you want to make changes in your life and the changes make sense and make you happy, then they are worth a sustained effort. But I wouldn't bother being rigid about it. That is to say, if you want to watch tv then watch tv and let others worry about themselves.
It's far more effective to enact change as you are ready then to force it because someone else is telling you it's the right thing to do.
Balance
Interesting post - great to see you approaching you and your child's life so thoughtfully.
My wife and I have a one-year old boy, and we have wrestled with many of the questions you have. We have made significant changes and achieved a balance that honors our commitment to being 'evolved', but that we can all live with comfortably. That sometimes means we bow to convenience. Like with the dryer - we use the clothesline and woodstove to dry things as much as possible, but sometimes the convenience and mission quickness of the dryer wins out - like if we need a load of our boy's cloth diapers dried quickly. Also, the clothesline doesn't do much good during our northeast winter, so the dryer gets more action.
Anyway, best of luck to the three of you!
I lived in Germany for 10
I lived in Germany for 10 yrs in the 90s and we never had a dryer. I found there, and also from my time living in NYC, that there are ways, sometimes creative, to handle getting clothes dry. In the winter, drying clothes helps to keep the humidity up during those winter months with more or less constant dry heat. In the summer, hanging clothes in the sun really dries them out quickly, if your washer has a good spin cycle. With clothes that need to be ironed, if you have them, ironing them while they are wet always seemed to me to get them extra smooth and wrinkle free. It wasn't nearly as much effort to get the wrinkles out.
The other stuff you mention, I do understand. My partner and I have the most difficulty with food, mostly because we are not feeding young children. We do not eat more than one real meal a day, and the rest of the time, we just munch on stuff. We cut off the tv a few months ago, and have found the streaming feature with netflix to be a real treasure trove of free documentaries about all of these issues. Michael Pollan, the author you mention, produced a video called 'The Botany of Desire' which is a fascinating look at 4 different cultivated plants and their histories. (You may also want to check out his book 'The Omnivore's Dilemma'.)
I may be an oddball even for new agey people, but I personally do not believe that children need to be around other children. They need to be around people who love them and talk to them as if they are people. That will give them the socialization skills they really need.
Home schooling can be difficult, either because of the parent's personality or the child's. But one thing I have wondered since my own son finished with that phase of his education was this: how expensive would it be for a group of parents, or rather parents representing 5-10 kids to pay a teacher to educate their kids? I mean, why is it a 'school' must be either a mom and her kids or some organization with dozens or even hundreds of people involved? Until you have experienced the interpersonal dynamic of a waldorf school and the juggling required to get any medium sized group of parents to agree on any comprehensive idea for all of their kids, it is difficult to describe the frustration that can be. I do not mean to criticize the waldorf pedagogic, I appreciated it very much. I am just saying consensus with others, whom you really know nothing about particularly regarding ideas on children, is difficult. The degree of difficulty is usually determined by how invested parents are in their own realities, as opposed to the larger collective reality, in the world or in your own local area, much like dealing with people about anything.
I appreciate your openness and sharing your process with us. Good luck!
Namaste,
Steve
eggonalimb.net
grok
Steve, I really like your idea of organizing 5-10 parents to pay for a teacher. That's a brilliant idea. And perhaps find a GREAT teacher, or a couple diverse part-timers, that can teach a good decent thing more than how to add, subtract, and write an analytical essay. I feel it would really catalyze a rebirth of passion in the teaching arts if that caught on.
But I might even suggest a few more families per group, for that's where I may differ with you a bit: I feel kids can greatly benefit by growing up with several peers, complete with their own dynamic predilections. It gives them the experience of growing and learning with others in a similar disposition rather than just having the experience of growing up TO the disposition of others. It helps to assuage their longing to grow up so fast and instead reap the benefits of wherever they are.
Any rate, good input folks.
:)
Thanks Giacomo.
I suppose I should stretch out that thought a bit and add that it is not that I feel children should be kept apart from one another. I just meant that it has at times looked like parents will make choices or be talked into choices on the basis of that idea that children must be with other children for a significant part of the day.
Of the people I have come to know and love and learn about who have childhood related issues, being around adults as opposed to children doesn't seem to have caused any trauma. It is rather the lack of love, the neglect and abuse, on whatever level that causes trauma and emotional issues. It has seemed to me in my life, and in the lives of people I've known, that children need just that, love - unconditional and irrevocable love.
I myself was loved by both parents, and it took me a long time to realize how many people are not. It is a humbling fact of life. We moved often, so long enduring friendships with my peers did not play a very important role for me and my siblings as it does for others.
I acknowledge I am merely the result of my experience and so the logic of what I'm trying to say could be limited in scope.
Namaste,
Steve
eggonalimb.net
Try to listen to your child
Try to listen to your child more than your husband when it comes to these issues. And I don't mean wait until they can talk and ask them what they think, listen to your body and your intuition. Your child is communicating with you.
I had been a vegetarian for 10 years before becoming pregnant and planned on raising my son vegetarian as well. Meat didn't look good, smell good or taste good to me. My second trimester came around and I craved chicken and tuna hardcore. So, I ate it. I ate it until a couple of months after I breastfed and now I am a vegetarian again. My son eats a mix of vegetarian meals and sometimes has meat with my grandparents. Maybe one day he will notice that I have made the decision not to eat meat and follow in my footsteps, but I am not going to force it on him. I believe that his body needed the extra protein to develop properly, so I gave it to him.
Also, when I was pregnant, I became aware that until he was born, I was this beings environment, and if I was scared or stressed out, he felt that. I also became very aware of how I feel in any given situation. I completely stopped watching the news, movies and tv that are scary or violent in any way, because those things stressed me out or make me tense. Since my son has been born, I completely stopped watching tv and I only watch movies in the theater, once in a blue moon, but I will admit I watched my share of mtv trash 'reality' when I was pregnant. lol.
In everything you have to weigh the pros and cons. For example, I thought that I wasn't going to let my son watch tv, but as a single parent, sometimes I need his attention in one place for 30 mins so I can get something done. If I don't let him watch it, and he wants my attention all day long, it wears on my nerves, and my interactions with him aren't as pleasant as I would like them to be. I personally believe that it is better for him to let him watch a bit of tv, and have me calm and collected when I interact with him. Than not let him watch it and risk me snapping at him. There is a lot of crap on tv, so I bought dvds of shows that I think are positive and that he can learn something from, and I put those on for him instead of hoping whatever is on isn't going to teach him or show him something bad. He squeals with delight when the theme song from world world comes on. He says the letters out loud, jumps around and dances with the tv. It feels right for him. As a mom, at least I needed breaks, and my sanity was more important to me than keeping him away from the TV.
Another example, it was important to me that my son and I had home cooked meals, and sat down at the table and ate as a family. When I was pregnant and for a while after my son was born, I was ill and had a couple of surgeries. I couldn't work and was on welfare and food stamps. In order for me to afford to feed us like I wanted to, a large part of my grocery shopping was done at Walmart. It was more important to me to feed him well than to shun corporations.
And now that I am back in school, I don't have time for home cooked meals every night. I believe it is more beneficial for my son for me to talk to him and play with him while the frozen chickn nuggets and homemade fries bake than for me to ignore him while I make something more elaborate.
The home school issue is the stickiest. I didn't hear you say that your husband was volunteering to stay home and make sure that your child got the education that they needed.
Ideally, I would like to have a network of other mom's and kids that I could home school and socialize my child with, but I don't actually see that happening. I don't have a partner so, if I stay home to home school my son, there isn't anyone to work to pay the bills. I will more than likely send him to private school. And he will survive. I went to private christian school and I broke out of the confines of the dogma that was presented to me and, I think, ended up with a pretty good head on my shoulders.
Although it would be nice to save all of humanity, your first responsibility is for yourself and your child. What is right for your child is not necessarily right for another and vice versa. Listen to your heart and listen to your child.
Although one can make a small impact on the lives of a stranger, by far the largest impact one can make is in the lives of their children. I believe that children first need your love, your patience, and your sanity. Give yourself and your child those things, and let the rest happen as it may.
Technology: I don't think a
Technology: I don't think a dryer should be such a divisive issue. It might save some money on energy bills, but hang-drying your clothes isn't going to save the world. I just moved to a house with no dryer and have yet to do any laundry, so I'll get back to you on that one.
Entertainment: When I was younger, we had our septic tank dug up and the cable for the satellite was accidentally cut. After a week my mom decided to call the tv company and have it fixed. As she began walking upstairs to make the call she saw my sister an I in the living room, and I was reading to my sister out of a Shel Silverstein book. She said to herself "we haven't had tv for a week and they're reading poetry?!" She decided not to get the tv hooked back up and it was the best decision my parents ever made for us. We had plenty of movies on VHS, but we couldn't waste hours upon hours in front of the tv. These days, with the internet and bit-torrent, you can have access to all the media you could ever want for much cheaper than in the past.
Consumerism: Anything you can do to reduce shopping is great. Learning how to fix or make your own things will also help your child develop many useful skills. Less shopping means less money needed which means less work and more time with your family.
Food: Food is the central organizing point of ANY and ALL societies. Teaching your child to prepare and cook food will instill good eating habits, and allows them to develop an intimate relationship/experience with what they eat. Use food to bind your family together. I very much regret that my family never had sit-down family dinners, and some of my best/only bonding time with my father was while cooking stews, making sausages, etc. It's not going to be the end of the world if you make an oven pizza on movie night. Also, please be sure to give your child proper nutrition. Meat and dairy intake should certainly be restricted, but don't go all fascist-vegan on the little ones.
Institutions: Schools aren't "like" prisons. They ARE prisons! I appreciate my parents giving me the education that they did, but at the same time I feel like school stifled every real opportunity for learning that I came across. I began taking graduate courses to become a teacher, and still aspire to be a math tutor, but as time went on I hated the current education model more and more. If there is ANY piece of advice that I can give to a parent is to keep your child's mind out of reach of that system. I can't tell you what alternative model to go with, you'll have to look into that yourself. But children WANT to learn, they seek it out. You don't have to give them a curriculum or tell them what they need to know. They will learn skills that they enjoy. Maybe they want to read, maybe they want to fix their bike, maybe they want to play strategy videogames all day. There's learning in everything.

Delicious
Digg
StumbleUpon
Propeller
Reddit
Magnoliacom
Newsvine
Furl
Facebook
Google
Yahoo
Technorati
Icerocket





