How to survive a 10 day Goenka Vipassana course
- Login or register to post comments
- Print this page
I just finished my first 10 vipassana retreat as taught by S.N. Goenka, and I just wanted to give a few words of advice for anyone considering taking a 10 day course.
For a report of an ecstatic vipassana experience, check out this blog from a fellow evolver.
http://www.evolver.net/user/jason_bowman/blog/vipassana_meditation_and_t...
Like any psychedelic experience the retreat is extremely challenging, but can be extremely rewarding also. Some people may decide to throw themselves into such an experience unprepared, and may do themselves serious trauma. However, taking a few precautions, and ensuring that the experience is right for you, can increase your chances of surviving this boot camp of the mind, and coming out stronger.
Below are a few recommendations and disclaimers that I have to give:
1. Be Buddhist.
... or at least be familiar with Buddhist terminology and philosophy. Take the time to study things like "dependent origination", the "five aggregates", the "Noble Eightfold Path", and the "Four Noble Truths". Being familiar with words like, anicca, dukkha, anatta, sankara, etc, will greatly aid you in understanding the theory of the practice as it is explained in the evening discourses.
As much as the teacher would like to claim that it is non-sectarian, the truth is that it is a Buddhist teaching. If you feel uncomfortable with bowing, chanting, and other cultural trappings of the East, then this may not be for you.
2. Practice Meditation.
These ten day courses should not be undertaken by total n00bs who have never tried to meditate seriously before. Even for casual meditators, a 10 day course is like being thrown into the deep end, and if you can't even tread water it will be terrifying. Practice mindfulness of breath, Satipatthana, sitting still for long periods of time, etc.
If you are need some basic instruction on the technique of vipassana to begin practicing before a retreat, I recommend:
"Mindfulness in Plain English"
http://www.urbandharma.org/pdf/mindfulness_in_plain_english.pdf
3. Do you trust your course organizers?
When you first arrive at your meditation camp it may feel a little strange. This is normal. But despite the strangeness of it you should feel safe, comfortable, and welcomed by your hosts. There are some stories out there of hellishly organized retreats with terrible hosts who have compromised the physical and psychological safety of meditators. If you feel that this may be the case with the retreat that you join, don't hesitate to leave if you don't feel that you are in a safe place. Trust is an integral part of receiving the teachings and practicing the technique. If this trust is absent then you will not have the positive and beneficial experience that you are supposed to.
4. Know your limits, and know how to push them safely.
Dislcaimer: there WILL be pain, there will be depersonalizing and deeply consciousness altering experiences. You will be pushing the limits of your mind and body throughout the course, and doing so in a reckless manner will likely get you hurt, physically, psychologically, or both.
DON'T BE A MASOCHIST! Some pain and discomfort are inevitable, but if you find yourself in excruciating pain then shift your posture, find a spot against the wall, etc. Torturing yourself is not the point of vipassana. And if your teacher cannot understand this, then you need to make your own judgements about how you want to continue the retreat, if at all.
5. Is this a cult? Am I being brainwashed?
Without being apologetic, yes, this is a cult and you are being brainwashed. In fact Buddhism is one of the oldest monastic cults of history. A Buddhist monk is required to give up their own individual identity, cut of all contact and meaningful relationships with the outside world, and allow their teachers/leaders to dictate their diet, dress code, sexuality, etc. If that's not a cult, then I don't know what is.
And for a short 10 days you will be living the life of a monastic.
You will be deprived of food, sleep, physical and social contact, and you will take a vow of celibacy before starting the course. You will be put in what is essentially an environment of sensory deprivation and forced to listen to the hypnotic instructions of S.N. Goenka.
But don't be frightened by this. Why else would you join such a retreat if your didn't want your mind cleansed of it's impurities (brainwashed)? What is important is that you know how to maintain your own ground, and walk the fine line of submitting to the instructors, and knowing when to assert your physical and psychological independence. That is why I recommend that you be able to trust the people organizing your retreat and that you feel safe. In the right hands, brainwashing techniques can be used for good.
(This is why I recommend being Buddhist. If you're already Buddhist then you won't mind being brainwashed into something that you already believe)
In order to maintain your own physical and psychological independence, do the following: Hang on to your keys and cellphone in case of an emergency (and ONLY in case of an emergency, don't be texting your friends! :) ). Don't be afraid to refrain from group chanting and other conformist activities. Don't just break the rules willy nilly and for fun, the rules are there for good reasons, but don't do anything that you aren't comfortable with. And if your hosts/teachers seem to be deceptive, manipulating, or try to induce fear or guilt, this is a sign that you need to leave.
6. On food, sleep, and silence.
For some people, the idea of not being able to talk for 10 days seems really difficult. Same goes for only eating twice a day and getting 6 hours of sleep a night.
But the truth is that after a few days of sitting around meditating, your body will adjust to the low calorie diet and you won't really feel hungry when dinner time comes.
Despite the external silence, your mind will be racing like a noisy chatterbox. Complete silence really is necessary for deep levels of awareness to be cultivated.
You will have a chance to take several naps during the day and this will help. Avoid sleeping through meditation periods, but if you feel that your fatigue has become counterproductive, then don't be afraid to extend your napping into meditation periods.
7. Integrating the experience.
Just like a psychedelic experience, you will have to integrate it before you can return to normal. This is what the tenth day is for, so if you haven't run away by the 6th day, then make the determination to stick it out to the end, because the final day will be of great help in integrating the experience.
*************************
These are all of my recommendations that I have for right now. I hope I haven't discouraged anyone from taking the course, but just like with psychedelics I feel that people need to be properly informed before undertaking such endeavors. It is really like a boot camp for your mind, and if you complete it successfully, you will feel that you have taken a giant leap towards mastering your mind and obtaining a tool/technique that is truly indispensable for exploring consciousness and reality.
With Metta,
~Vincent
Comments
a different view....
I've done a couple of vipassana retreats, and alot of the info in this post is VERY misleading from my perspective. I'm not going to comment on everything, because there is just too much erroneous information to even bother with it.
Just let me say....
Vipassana is definately a psychedelic experience. If you consider it "challenging" then you are trying. The harder you try the less likely your success. The more "unprepared" you are for it the BETTER! A true conscious shift must come from a surprise. The more you prepare, the less the surprise. The teachings come from a buddhist, but they can very easily be applied to any philosophy.
Vincent - If you really just finished a 10 day course (which I find very hard to believe) then please consider taking another one. Or maybe a massive dose (at least 3x what you think is reasonable) of your favorite psychedelic will be more beneficial. Alone in nature or in a ceremonial setting of course.
"If you're not afraid you did too much, you haven't done enough" - TM
Very good blog. I thought
Very good blog. I thought about taking the 10 day vipassana course myself and this was very informative. I just felt a strong desire to go on the retreat after lots of mantras, I wanted to take it to the next level. The whole retreat is like a crash course in becoming fractal!
Money-a symbol for the efficient distribution of human energy.
I think that any view point
I think that any view point from anyone who has gone through vippasana is valuable. I enjoyed your advice and will consider it before going. “An invasion of armies can be resisted, but not an idea whose time has come.”-Victor Hugo
I finished my first ten day
I finished my first ten day course in Thailand, two months ago - came back to Bangkok and was quite buried in the chaotic vibrations of Khao San Road hahaha. Back in the US now and still I feel completely altered. After taking a long break from straight years of psychedelic plant insight, having had many many transformative ego dissolutions/near deaths/and or deaths?, I came away with the clear feeling that Vipassana was so incredibly healthier (and quite as intense!) than most of what I engaged in psolitarily. I think psychedelics are effective for the western mind to break in/out, but then there are many systems (Including Vipassana) that are the quite necessary next step in psychic development.
Ritual use of plant teachers by indigenous peoples is quite different from a westerner taking psychedelics alone/with friends. Vipassana (and many other systems) is good for westerners to learn to grow with guidance - which is very important especially right now.
I heartily recommend Vipassana! Still keeping my practice up when life allows. A very effective deprograming technique, and I'm surprised no one commented on Goenka's gentle sense of humor....
I agree with most of what
I agree with most of what your saying, although I went against many of your warnings with my first course, and I came out of it with more understanding and serenity than I have ever experienced. Yes, it is somewhat secular, despite the claims to the contrary. As has been stated, the course is a very effective form of brainwashing, although not in the common sense of the word. The whole point, in my opinion, was to facilitate a mental breakdown in a supportive setting, and then allow each individual to build back up in their own unique way. Yes, certain values are communicated, such as love, equanimity, clarity, and compassion, but these are presumably the values one hopes to attain from the course from the outset. What separates this course from other spiritual classes is one: The length and intensity of the course, jumping into 10 days of sensory deprivation and physical discomfort is no easy task. And two: You can confirm the absolute truth of what Goenka is saying as you go. The results of one full day of meditation are very real and tangible on both the mental and physical level, and that in my mind makes this course an invaluable option for anyone looking to dig deeper. Add the fact that the monetary aspect is completely secondary, with donation being the only form of income for the meditation center. All the teachers and workers are freely donating their time to be there, and so it is completely free from the corruption of money. Although Goenka does make claims to the superiority of his technique, I feel that this type of meditation lays a great foundation for any other spiritual practice, from yoga to entheogens, as well as being complete on it's own.
I went into this course with no former meditation experience, and little understanding of buddhist traditions, and only through sheer determination was I able to make it to the end. I thought I was going crazy multiple times, and there were definitely some dark moments on a daily basis. However, if it weren't for the course, I would still be carrying around that darkness deep in my brain, rather than letting it slide through awareness into non-existence. Overall, it was one of the best things I have ever done and I plan to do it again as soon as possible.
As much as the teacher would
As much as the teacher would like to claim that it is non-sectarian, the truth is that it is a Buddhist teaching.
Word.
I've been on two of those retreats. I always thought that the frequent claim that the retreats were areligious were ridiculous.
Dependent origination is about as deep of a Buddhist concept as you can get and it is all over the videos used to teach the course.
I don't think anyone gets upset about it, because nobody is telling anyone to pray to a different god.
I've been to two of Goenka's
I've been to two of Goenka's 10 day courses. I think calling it a psychedelic experience, brainwashing or deprogramming is misleadingly extreme.
It is 10 days of meditation. You spend a few days noticing when you breathe in and out. You spend the last several days doing a body scan with your mind, noticing what physical sensations you feel.
Add in being distracted by how stiff your legs feel from sitting, a few day dreams, relaxation and some caffiene-high like experiences and you have a mostly good description of the experiences there.
5. Is this a cult? Am I
5. Is this a cult? Am I being brainwashed?
Without being apologetic, yes, this is a cult and you are being brainwashed. In fact Buddhism is one of the oldest monastic cults of history. A Buddhist monk is required to give up their own individual identity, cut of all contact and meaningful relationships with the outside world, and allow their teachers/leaders to dictate their diet, dress code, sexuality, etc. If that's not a cult, then I don't know what is.
I don't mean to be a jerk, but this comment simply isn't true.
Psychologists and other degreed professionals have very well articulated definitions of what a cult is. Neither Buddhism or Goenka's meditation retreats fit that definition.
I go to two Sri Lankan Buddhist temples in my area. They do not cut off ties with the outside world and their peeps. In fact, many monks travel a lot and have a huge crew of people all over the world that they stay in touch with.
The monk who runs one of the temples I go to gets regular visits from his sister and her family.
You will be deprived of
You will be deprived of food, sleep, physical and social contact, and you will take a vow of celibacy before starting the course. You will be put in what is essentially an environment of sensory deprivation and forced to listen to the hypnotic instructions of S.N. Goenka.
Not true.
As you wrote elsewhere in this post, you do not feel hungry when you are on the course. Sitting still all day in meditation lowers your metabolism. The two meals a day are all you can eat and feature a variety of interesting vegetarian meals with several choices of entrees and side dishes.
There is no sleep deprivation. People attending the retreat go to bed at about 9:30 pm and get up around 4:30 am. That is 7 hours of sleep a day.
I wouldn't call the vow of silence "being cut off from social contact" either. You are surrounded by people and busy meditating. The vow of silence ends on the last day and half of the course and most people spend a huge amount of time talking.
Nobody is "forced to listen to the hypnotic instructions of S.N. Goenka.". The meditation instructions and philosophical instructions on the retreats are given via videotapes of S.N. Goenka. I think that sucks, so much else is impersonal these days. Those videos however are not "hypnosis".
Goenka merely gives people meditation directions.
For the record, I am no fan of the Goenka Meditation retreats. I've been to two of his retreats. I stopped going because of the authoritarian, arrogant and superstitious subculture of the people who run the places --- the exact opposite qualities I have come to expect from the Buddhist subculture.
I think the pre-retreat
I think the pre-retreat recommendations in this post are good.
The only things I would add are
1. Get up early the week before the retreat.
Many people aren't used to getting up at 4:30 a.m. The ones that do on the retreat don't function well and get the most out of their time. Other people simply can't cut it, sleep in and miss large portions of the retreat.
2. Bring Earplugs
You will hear a lot of snoring and other noises in the sleeping area. The silence of the retreat will make you more sensitive to noise.
3. Leave a day in between the end of the retreat and your return to work
Your nervous system will adjust to the silence of the retreat. The city will seem overwhelming when you first get back. A day yourself to adjust is nice.
short christmas wishes
Like any psychedelic practical see the getaway is incredibly complicated, but can be incredibly worthwhile also. Some people may decide to put themselves into such an practical knowledge not really prepared, and may do themselves serious tension. short christmas wishes | christmas wishes sms | christmas wishes poems
I have to say that the in a
I have to say that the in a row here was the most Michael Jackson music absolute that I found anywhere camping meals . I am positively bookmarking this to come back residential painting contractors ma and read later.
Well, that is one point of view.
That being said I would consider it a rare and narrow minded one.
It is worth bearing in mind that although this gentleman seems to think that being Buddhist is essential S N Goenka is in fact Hindu and stresses many times the non-sectarian and scientific principles that lay behind this practice.
This is about freedom, not being part of cult, another thing stressed right from the outset.
I devised a more practical and perhaps more sensible site here some time ago following my first 10 day course.
You can view that here: https://sites.google.com/site/introtovipassana/
I wish you all every happiness.
Thank you,
Phil.

Delicious
Digg
StumbleUpon
Propeller
Reddit
Magnoliacom
Newsvine
Furl
Facebook
Google
Yahoo
Technorati
Icerocket





